Tuesday, 11 December 2007

The Reality...

...is that I spent the entire evening listening to music and dancing around my house with the lights off (decorators took the blinds down.) I forgot: my other addiction.

Now tell me, which is the all time greatest Christmas song. This?



Or this?



16 comments:

Anonymous said...

Well, personally, I adore "People Look East" for Advent, "Sussex Christmas Carol" for Christmas, and "The Band of Children" for Epiphany. However, you're looking for secular pop/rock-type stuff, aren't you? What about the song that *really* tells it like it is: "The St Stephen's Day Murders" by Elvis Costello? You gotta love a song that works "that drink made of girders" into the lyrics. (May I also sneak in mentions of "2000 Miles" by The Pretenders, "River" by Joni Mitchell [the cry-into-your-Molson Christmas-song for Canadians, especially since Marie closed down her other blog] and "Father Christmas" by Ray Davies? No? Well, I do also love "A Fairytale of New York". But apparently so does everyone else.)

Anonymous said...

"the boys of the NYPD choir were singing Galway Bay" - I've always found that line inexplicably moving.

I'd add Darlene Love singing her heart out on "Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)" from the Phil Spector Chrimbo album as a favourite of mine. And I'd nominate "Just Like Christmas" by Low for the acclaimed "Best use of jingle bells in a cool indie song. Ever" award.

Off to check out Elvis C singing about Irn Bru...

Vanessa said...

'Santa Baby' by Marilyn Monroe. And I'm also another person who finds the line about the NYPD choir very moving.

Marie said...

I found an incredibly sexy Kylie version of that on YouTube which I nearly posted as option three, but the problem was is that the entire set-up suggests that Kylie is going to strip - she's wearing a long gown which ties at the back, and at one point throws off her furs - and through the whole thing I was waiting for her to take her clothes off, and she doesn't. And if I found that frustrating as a heterosexual woman, I thought it might actually kill some of my male readers.

Alis said...

OK, this will age me but does anyone else out there remember Jonah Louis'Can You stop the Cavalry (Wish I was at Home for Christmas)? must have been about 1980-ish. It's probably just the vaguely New-Romantic army uniform he was wearing in the video but it's always stuck in my mind!
Oh, and Persephone, don't you love pretty much everything Maddy Prior has ever done with traditional carols?

Karen said...

I remember Can you Stop the Cavalry! Good song, but my favourite Crimble tune is Walking in a Winter Wonderland.

Unknown said...

I like "I was born on Christmas day" by Saint Etienne. I am always surprised when I hear it in shops around this time of year. Though I second both Can you stop the Calvary and Low.

Anonymous said...

Alis, how did you guess??? (I'm a little scared now...) I own pretty much everything Maddy ever recorded. (Slips off to slip "Carols and Capers into the CD player.)

RandomPinkness said...

You have managed to choose my two favorite xmas songs... I am torn... No I can't do it I can't decide! I am, however, going to download them both. Also I'm with Persephone River is fab too.

Anonymous said...

Sorry, sorry, sorry, it's not about Christmas songs, no, THIS IS EVEN MORE IMPORTANT. I've tried to find something on it on Google, but I can't, I mean come ON, what's the internet for? I've just been gasping at Strictly ITT. Matt and Flavia's training footage. The evidence, M'lud: A) her lipstick has been completely kissed off and you can see her lips are a bit sore from so much snogging B) at the end of the footage she says is there anything else you want to add to that, he murmurs "mmmmm", he goes in to kiss her and she leans towards him... and then CUT! OMG, it's true, I am just too excited, did you see it, did you see it?!!!

Marie said...

NO, BECAUSE MY TELEVISION IS STILL UNDER DUST SHEETS!!! CURSES!!! I AM MISSING EVERYTHING!!!

Anonymous said...

I looked on youtube but it's not there yet. It will be though I am certain. If I find it I'll post the link - it's too exciting for words. Here's what my best friend said "We have just all watched the FlavMat debacle all I can say is OH MY GOD! We couldn't believe it!!!!!"

Hope you manage to see it soon.

Anonymous said...

Here it is. Around 5 minuted in http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B8On_tjlUHc

However, I am now furious because if you look on the studio monitor on the right as the clip ends and camera pulls back, Flavia touches his face but pulls away rather than leans in. Damnation, this is still not resolved. (I'm getting too obsessed by this aren't I?)

Marie said...

Thanks for posting that missbabs! i thnk this is very significant evidence for the following reasons:

1. He goes for the kiss but she pushes him away.
2. The BBC chose to cut *before* she pushes him away.

That can mean one of two things. Either that there was a fling (he goes for the kiss) but it is now over (she pushes him away plus beeb does not have better footage of monkey business to use) OR that there *is* a fling but Flavia doesn't want people to know about it so won't let Matt kiss her on camera.

The other thing to note is, as Alice pointed out in the comments to another thread, just how jealous Matt looks when he is sitting on the sofa with Flavia and Vincent.

I'm super-impressed with the producers for abusing a young man's feelings and getting Vincent and Flavia together constantly, just in order to ramp up the tension for we grateful viewers. Kudos to those stone-hearted folk!

Anonymous said...

No, Christmas Wrapping by the Waitresses! Although it does duke it out quite manfully with The Pogues (Shane probably quite drunk to give the waitresses a chance).

Anonymous said...

Okay, I'm not proud of this, but I cannot bear it any longer: 1) Marilyn Monroe *never* recorded "Santa Baby". Look it up. This is yet another internet-engendered myth. 2) "Winter Wonderland" is not a Christmas song. This is nothing to do with being secular; there are plenty of secular songs about Christmas. ("Santa Baby" for example.) But you can sing "Winter Wonderland", "Let It Snow", "Baby It's Cold Outside", or even "Jingle Bells" at any time of year, providing it's snowing (or in the case of "BICO", even if it's reasonably chilly).
There. I feel better. Does anyone else?