
Easter Saturday, 2009. By the machinations of a small hand-held device unlikely to be picked up by Apple any time soon, the Doctor is sucked into a wormhole and ends up in a Bond movie, complete with Bond girl (Michelle Ryan) and Q (Lee Evans). Is there any way out?
With the Christmas specials bound to be Who Mood A - dark, overblown, with fantastic cliffhanger at the end of episode two ruined by dreadful quasi-religious resolution in episode three - this Easter special was Who Mood B: big, dumb fun, sweet as a chocolate egg and not nearly as sickly.
It could have gone horribly wrong. Amidst the schmaltz of the "forget about the fact you're on an alien planet with three suns, what really matters in this life is chops and gravy" scene - not a very Doctoresque sentiment, I might add - I feared that this was going to be yet another "ordinary folk pull together" type morality tale, but the episode pretty much abandoned the bus passengers after that. Instead, what we got was a lot of flirtation between the Doctor and that Michelle Ryan character - what was her name again? Tickle McWim? Yup, it wasn't only the desert that was hot.
This was Doctor Who: The Sexy Special (PG rating, contains mild peril and a lot of embarrassing innuendos.) Poor Michelle Ryan: not the most convincing actress at the best of times, as Tickle McWim she had to deliver a lot of lines which may as well have been suffixed with the words JUST LIKE SEX. "I like things extreme" - JUST LIKE SEX. "We could be good together" - IN THE SACK. Unfortunately this bled into every other line that she said. "There's sand in the engine" - AND IN MY PANTS. When she wasn't being sexy, she was being sexy and posh: "That's how the aristocracy survives, by being ready for everything" (AND BY SHAGGING LOADS), she says, before diving down some kind of giant vent thing to rescue a crystal (shades of The Crystal Maze, anyone?) Everything, except for the Icelandic banks collapsing, apparently. Poor Daddy.
But who cares? It was good to see the Doctor getting flirty and dirty. The harder it gets the more he loves it, apparently - me too, baby. His tongue got an excellent workout, both licking the sand and snogging Michelle at the end, with not a DNA transfer excuse in sight. Of course, he kissed and ran - you can't have shagging in the Tardis, as DT often says. Perhaps Ms McWim will turn up on Torchwood? I'd like to see her face off with Captain Jack - BETWEEN THE SHEETS.
This wasn't the only love affair in Planet of the Dead. The other, and, I hope, the more lasting of the two, was between the Doctor and Lee Evans's Malcolm, a UNIT boffin and sort of genetic splice of Q and Rob Brydon. Watching Evans in action it was hard to believe he hadn't been a series regular since day one. Doctor Who needs a comedy scientist, stands to reason, if only to say lines like, "Doctor, what if I reverse the proton polarity of the anhydrous electromagnet and increase to a force of fifteen Bernards? Oops, my glasses have fallen off." [Disclaimer: may not actually have been what he said]. By the time they were back-and-forthing on the phone, I felt as if they had known each other for years. When they finally came face to face, and Evans delivered his excellent and heartfelt series of "I love you"s, I thought he was going to go in for the snog too. Disappointingly, he didn't, but if Malcolm loves the Doctor, I love Malcolm, and beg Mr Moffat to please bring him back soon.
There were other fabulous details, too numerous to mention. The shit-eating alien flies, who don't have ears but who do have perfect ear-shaped communications devices lying around their spaceship. The fact that a skeleton falling out of a wormhole is "Emergency Code One" which rather makes you wonder what happened at the meeting where they dreamed up the emergency codes, and whether Emergency Code Two is "Tower Bridge unmoors itself and starts dancing the Macarena". The fact that the only thing that can make a London bus run on time is an ancient gold cup "worth 18 million pounds". Have I made myself clear yet? I absolutely loved it from beginning to end.
Next time: "Water always wins": the Doctor is unexpectedly killed by a urine infection.

20 comments:
Yes! After reading lots of depressingly negative reviews (Digital Spy, I'm looking at you), the lovely Marie, whose opinion I actually care about, agrees with me. It was great, and Malcolm was its crowning glory.
Aw, thanks Anna!
Thanks for the giggles Marie!
Well, I did start to type a whole reply up, but then realised I was just rambling on your blog instead of mine! (So, in case you're interested, I've waffled on there instead.)
I've not read any other reviews, so don't know what everyone else is saying. I didn't love it, but it was certainly distracting enough and great fun, even though I really didn't like Lady Bionic Catsuit very much at all.
We certainly agree about Malcolm, though. Love Malcolm. Need Malcolm back. More Malcolm, Moff!
I discovered you quite recently, at first because I was looking for one certain Doctor. So, before I say anything else, let me say that I think you're brilliant. This blog is among the funniest I've read so far, and I've kept coming back for the past week, reading up on you.
Further more: thanks for a splendid review! Knowing that you would write one made it less sad when Planet of the Dead reached it's final minutes, so: thank you.
And as you might have noticed through my shameless praise, I agree with you, it was lovely. But then again, I tend to think they always are, as long as Tennant is a part of it. And Malcolm! Finally someone who loves the doctor, but does not try to sneak into the sheets of the Tardis. Not to mention the best moment of the Doctor /Malcolm romance, when M. hung up on his hero, and the latter felt rejected.
It's gonna be a long time till late August.
Haha! Great review, made me smile much like the episode itself. As something that may interest you, I have a piece about the Tennant/Smith exchange and one about the new trend of 'Kissy-Face Doctor' up on my site-thing, 21Pimlico.com under the 'Articles' section.
I'm new at all this 'Net malarkey so I hope the above isn't crude or pushy or anything, so new into our 'cyber-acquaintance'. I'm learning my etiquette as I go!
Happy Easter, Bunnies!
Erin.
Man, now I wis her name really was Tickle McWim.
I enjoyed it, and Michelle Ryan as well. Couldn't believe she once was the Bionic Zombie.
Liked the tip of the hat to Quatermass, but just wish it hadn't been so "clunky". The big reveal of the "Bernard" was all for the sake of a joke that just didn't feel right. Quibbling, I know.....
Anyhoo, great review and I'm glad there are pockets of resistance out there who enjoyed it!
Links to your own sites are always welcome, people. Not pushy at all unless you are a spambot.
Glad to see there are some fellow episode-lovers or at least likers here, as the general feeling out there on the web is a thumbs down. How can people thumbs down Malcolm? I reckon they all felt sick from too much chocolate.
Glad you liked the tongue-action - RTD must be reading this blog.
I thought the episode was OK, but lots of re-hashing; even Malcolm is a re-hash of an old ad campaign. Time for a reimagining of the reimagining, methinks.
Oh I loved it too. It was so much fun. And silly. I like my Dr Who silly. Haven't had time to blog it yet (and can't even begin to compete with this hilarious review), but will do at some point when I can throw the children off the computer long enough...
Jeez it looks like i am in the minority here - I was okay with Lady Christina and couldn't stand Malcolm.
I quite liked it, but these kind of episodes are the ones I like.
OK, good! Wasn't totally sure.
I re-watched the ep. today and I have to say that every time Lady JewelThief opened her mouth, I kept thinking, 'IN MY PANTS' or 'IN THE SACK' after whatever she said. It's like that thing people do with fortune cookies - 'You will meet someone who fulfills all your dreams' and you're supposed to say 'in bed'.
(Going to give this Google Blogger thing a go but if it doesn't work, I'll sign...)
Erin.
Have you read Off The Telly's review? And we thought Digital Spy's was bad!
http://www.offthetelly.co.uk/?p=6876
I started to write a witty and cutting blog in response but I keep getting distracted by shaking my head in disbelief. Please do it for me!
The Off The Telly Review: A Summary:
"She was a THIEF. It's IMMORAL. Also, the police were made to look INCOMPETENT. Why didn't the Daily Mail get the review the script before the episode went out?"
Holy smoke...
Ohhh, now, I thought it was splendid! A nice big romp before it gets all dark and cloister bell-y. And for once RTD managed to come up with a scary monster that could do serious damage (even if he did nick the idea from the Matrix. The stingrays were totally Sentinels, weren't they?) It was the kind of episode RTD used to write for Christopher Ecclestone before he was only allowed to write the big show-stopping finales, and therefore had to make them Deep and Meaningful and Emotional. Big stingrays on an alien planet with a randy jewel thief, yeah!
Thanks for the great review, I'm going to be one who loved it! : )
Just to prove it, and since you said you don't mind our own links...I diverged from photography to post about it. lol!
http://rachelellice.blogspot.com/2009/04/departure.html
Great review! My own favourite bits were Malcolm, the gadgety thingumy bit at the start and the tongue action. It was great to have a bit of fun before everyone starts wearing their serious faces and the orchestra gets all portentious.
I've now got to the point where any scenario that presents the possibility of gratuitous licking (with glasses preferably!) is anticipated as a "marie moment"!
Seriously though, didn't we all know that from the trailer of dropping sand through his fingers crouching down on the desert that the Doctor simply HAD to do the whole licking thing?!
In case you haven't guessed, yep, much enjoyed. Silly, frothy, totally unnecessary to the general Who canon but nevertheless utterly enjoyable fun.
Pedants and Daily Mail-esque reviewers can go hang.
Wonderful review, Marie. I laughed - a lot.
The trouble I have when watching Doctor Who is that my critical faculties hide themselves in a dark cupboard and stick their fingers in their ears. I had no idea that there had even been any negative reviews and find the whole concept of putting 'disappointment' in the same thought process as 'Doctor Who' as alien as flies in jump-suits.
Erm, I loved every daft moment of it.
Post a Comment