Wednesday, 4 February 2009

Reader Getting Barcelona. Or something.

It won't have escaped the attention of UK readers that, it being Oscar season, enough good films to keep us going for an entire year are being released within one month, guaranteeing that even the most dedicated film-goers will miss a decent chunk of them, and have to spend the rest of the year watching Knocked Up 2: Knocked Down - The Domestic Violence Years!* and wishing they were at Slumdog Millionaire / Milk / Revolutionary Road / Frost Nixon / Doubt / The Wrestler / The Reader / Rachel Getting Married / Vicky Cristina Barcelona instead. To help you in your film-choosing misery, I am thus reviewing the films off that list which I have already seen, so that you don't (necessarily) have to. It's novel, it's innovative, it's a public service.

Anyway.

1. The Reader. Begins with the most graphic and protracted vomiting scene since John Hurt, or possibly Ian Holm (I can't tell them apart), spewed up the Alien in Alien. Through his chest! But you know, that's what vomiting feels like. Anyway, this scene is somewhat less necessary than that one, given as The Reader (surprisingly) is not about a monstrous vomit creature. My first piece of advice: arrive ten minutes late. As for the rest of the movie, it is mostly remarkable for the amount of time Kate Winslet spends in the nude, showing off her authentic body hair. If she wins the Oscar, it will be for services to armpit hair, in the tradition of giving Oscars to beautiful women for playing ugly (cf Charlize Theron, Nicole Kidman etc.) Kate doesn't play it that ugly - she has a perfectly honed gym body, as you'd expect on a 1950s German bus conductor - but she does walk like a sack of potatoes on legs, to emphasise her unprettiness. Other irritations include the syrupy music poured over absolutely everything to let you know how you feel, as we wouldn't want to risk someone coming out a post-holocaust movie with the wrong opinion, because that would be WRONG, and the fact that everyone in the film affects a German accent, to emphasise that the film is set in Germany, and about Germans, otherwise you might forget. More positively, the film is absolutely competently executed in every way and not actively a waste of your time, and there is loads of sex.

2. Vicky Cristina Barcelona. Everything you'd expect from a good Woody Allen movie (forget the last decade or two) - except less. Intellectual discussion - but less of it! Furrow-browed angsting - but less of it! Awkward social interaction - but less of it! Clever humour - but less of it! And so on. The only thing there is more of is more pretty young women (Penelope Cruz, Scarlet Johannson and Rebecca Hall) indulging in more tortured love triangles with a more sexy than Woody lead Javier Bardem. You know, that does make it worth it. But manage your expectations.

3. Rachel Getting Married. OK, so this is the one to see. From the title and the casting of Anne Hathaway I was expecting a chick flick nightmare, but what I got was a highly intelligent, beautifully performed, wonderfully directed film which is about as close as you can get to actually going to a wedding without having to eat any sugared almonds. The entire film takes place over a wedding weekend for a huge wedding, and is filmed handheld and semi-improvised so that you feel like another guest. The "front" story is Hathaway's return from rehab for her sister's wedding and the impact that has on her family. This is bravely handled by the screenplay which refuses to give you obvious "good guy" and "bad guy" characters for you to side with or hate. I spent half the movie in painful sympathy with Hathaway, and the other half wanting to slap her. Wait a moment, that's how I feel about myself. The "back" story is the wedding itself which provides way more than a living backdrop. It's a wonderful seething mass of wedding, which, like a real wedding, is alternately sentimental, moving, boring, exciting, going on for far too long, punctuated with moments of magic, padded out with semingly endless speeches and so on. All of the incidental music in the film is "real" ie comes from wedding guests and band practising, performing or just noodling away. I thought this film was fantastic and a virtuoso effort from Jonathan Demme. One not to miss - hat optional, no gifts please.

*May not actually be a movie.

18 comments:

Anonymous said...

aha, excellent. You are providing a useful public service here... am going to see the Wrestler tomorrow, so will report back...

Marie said...

Ooh yes, report back here please. Maybe everyone can post their reviews of the Oscar contenders here so that we can get a WWTTM consensus on which were the good movies, performances etc, and then have our own mini-Oscars, without having to bother to all go see all the movies and make up our minds independently. Saves time and money!

Anonymous said...

I'm going to see Revolutionary Road tonight after staying up til stupid o'clock last night to finish the book. An amazing read, although I do worry about how it's translated to the big screen, as so much of the critical detail is thought and felt. I shall report back...

Persephone said...

Yes, but how authentic was Kate Winslet's pubic hair? I don't suppose you got to see that... I liked the book, which may mean I'd find the movie disappointing.

I can recommend Frost/Nixon for edge-of-the-seat suspense in a non-violent film. It took me about twenty minutes to get used to Michael Sheen as David Frost and Frank Langella as Nixon, but that's because I'm familiar with both the real-life characters and the actors playing them. Kevin Bacon was a wonder.

Milk is a labour of love which owes a heavy debt to The Times of Harvey Milk which is simply one of the best documentary films I've ever seen. See both.

Oh and if you haven't seen Happy-Go-Lucky (which I believe is up for Best Screenplay, you should. People either love it or hate it. I loved it.

Marie said...

According to the interview I read with her, Kate's pubic hair was entirely authentic. I can report that you see plenty of it and that it is very black. The Oscar will go for the armpits though - it is still just about acceptable for a woman to have hair between her legs, but under her arms? NEVER.

Raye S. said...

As a member of the public availing myself of this service, I am almost moved to watch "Rachel Getting Married". But that might just be because I have the same name and it's spelled the same...
...but then that is something.

Marie said...

Do it Raye! You can blame me if it all goes horribly wrong. Also, it's not a very long film.

Anonymous said...

Don't waste 2 1/hours of your life watching The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. Beautiful to look at but long, long, long. Instead, read F. Scott Fitzgerald's brilliantly ironic short story in 20 minutes. And Anne Hathaway was amazing but I'm afraid she'll lose the Oscar to Kate Winslet's body hair.

Marie said...

Benjamin Button! I knew I'd forgotten (at least) one.

Anne Hathaway should definitely (but won't) beat Kate, and Rachel Getting Married should have got more nominations in general. The truly glaring omission, though, is Kristin Scott Thomas in I've Loved You So Long - easily the performance of the year - and I am so baffled to see it overlooked that I'm assuming it wasn't Oscar eligible. Can someone knowledgeable advise?

CPMatthew said...

Marie - do you have time to write a newsletter for us?

(Re bodyhair - Charlotte Roche author of Wetlands - used to shock people on German TV by proudly displaying her bodyhair...Clearly the only way she could top that was to write a book about a lass who is obsessed with her - insert latest feminist friendly word for vagina here)

Thank the lord you can't blush via the internet.

Anonymous said...

Ok, so, The Wrestler is awesome, go see it. Brilliant performance from Mickey Rourke (wow, though, how strange does he look these days?...) and from Marisa Tomei as a slightly raddled looking stripper. It's fascinating, touching, funny. Recommended!

Unknown said...

I agree with Marie that RGM is excellent. I suppose I didn't love it quite as much, though. There were one or two big plot implausibilities...but worse was the insistent, smug, ostentatious, box-ticking multi-culturalism (wow, this wedding is like a beautiful rainbow, man). I left the cinema feeling like Oswald Moseley and I can tell you that's not a pleasant sensation. But overall - what she says. I also agree with Jessica's assessment of The Wrestler. Go see. A conventional storyline. But well told. And brilliantly acted. It's all about The Mickey.

Marie said...

Ian, I thought that was deliberately grim, cringe-inducing, hideous, 'why the hell are they having an Indian wedding when she's Jewish and he's black' thing, designed to make you shudder with recognition if you've ever been to a repellantly over-the-top do yourself. But maybe not.

Anonymous said...

It also has a fantastic soundtrack.

Persephone said...

Just getting my impressions of the film The Reader down at my blog (because I've joined that NaBloPoMo thing for February): I'm a bit puzzled about your remark that "everyone in the cast affects a German accent". The cast is all German, with the exception of most of the leads (and for some odd reason, Linda Bassett, who plays Hannah's prison social worker): Kate Winslet and Ralph Fiennes are British; Bruno Ganz is Swiss (and therefore a German speaker), and Lena Olin is Swedish. Wouldn't their speaking in their natural accents been more distracting? Also, it was after the sex scenes were nearly over that I realized that I had failed to clock any of Kate Winslet's body hair. I must have been distracted as well...

Marie said...

Ah well, it kind of depends whether they decided that everyone would have a German accent before they cast it or after. But maybe I'm just over-sensitive having been scarred by watching Allo Allo for years, which I imagine is not so much of a problem in Canada.

Persephone said...

'Allo 'Allo is available here, however, every time I've attempted to watch it, I've failed to find it funny. Is that terribly un-British of me?

Marie said...

No. You are right.