Sunday, 3 April 2011

Spiral S3 ep 1 & 2

Well. That was grim, wasn't it? My first mental note was: do not watch this and eat at the same time. In the first two minutes we had WHORES! TITS! BLOW-JOB! EVISCERATED CORPSE IN A BIN BAG WITH HER TITS CUT OFF! The Killing this isn't. God, wasn't The Killing nice? I mean, sure, it didn't end well for Nanna Birk Larssen, but oh to be in a nation so sleepy that mayoral debates are apparently televised every night, where the worst vices the police can muster up are nicotine gum and junk food, and even the murdered takes time out from his killing spree to go shopping for puppies. By the end of two episodes of Spiral, we had another girl in a bin bag (tits yet to be accounted for), a paedophile with a Terry Thomas moustache, several buckets of chicken blood, a small child ripped to pieces by a dog (off camera, thankfully), a corrupt lawyer getting shot three times at point blank range but surviving (the head, people! aim for the head!), a nasty posh lady in a Chanel boucle two-piece and a particularly ugly broach getting done for drunk driving, the judge's bitch-mum having a stroke, the police inspector hating her home life so much she's sleeping in her car, some casual betrayal, a really skanky nightclub, a teenager getting accused of sleeping with her own dad, a shoe-collecting vagrant smoking dope in the park, occurrences of corruption too numerous to mention, one of the most repulsive double chins I have ever seen, plenty of child neglect, did I mention the buckets of chicken blood, entire buildings crammed with illegal immigrants and homeless people, a missing earring, and my own particular favourite moment, an innocent suspect being punched in the stomach by the police until he vomits and then rolled in his own sick. Did I miss anything out?

Being half French, I can help you out with some of the things you might have found confusing. Judges in France, for example, don't wait around for the evidence to be brought to them in court. They take an active role in the investigation, and at the trial they retire with the jury and, unbelievably, direct them on their verdict. They are all-powerful super-crusading mega-judges in other words, and thus favour full hairstyles with silvery highlights. Defense lawyers and prosecutors are similarly up to their necks.

Also, you may have missed the full force of profanity which has been toned down for the subtitles. I can only imagine the meeting at the BBC4 translation unit where they decided how many shits and fucks they were going to allow per episode. But you can bet that when the subtitles say "Get off my back," what the character has actually just said is "Stop riding my arse, you cunt." To their boss. My favourite French swearword has no equivalent in English. It's "bordel", which means "brothel", and can be used in almost any context. "What is this brothel?", "This situation in which I find myself is a brothel," or just plain "Brothel!" when under duress, sometimes supplemented as "bordel de merde!" ie "Brothel of shit!" If we can get the British walking around saying "Brothel of shit!" then Spiral's work will be done.

To be honest with you, I'm not sure I'm going to make it to the end of twelve episodes of this. I'm exhausted already. And we can't even play along with "find the suspect" because there aren't a lot of useful candidates hanging around, wearing knitted beanie hats, being suspiciously good at teaching, or appearing on televised mayoral debates. Plus, no jumpers. I guess it's not that cold in Paris. What did you think?

12 comments:

Marie said...

How could I have forgotten 'teenage girl getting her friend to video her losing her virginity to her friend's dad'? I am a lousy reviewer.

Persephone said...

Oh. Heavens. Back here in Canada the Tame, Persephone the Squeamish will be dithering this evening between the first episode of The Borgias which has the plus of Jeremy Irons, but will undoubtedly be uh...graphic, and the American version of The Killing which the critics say will be good but will also be, given the title, violent. Or I can wimp out entirely and go with whatever is on Masterpiece Theatre tonight, which is probably Jane bloody Austen again...

Spiral? No thanks. The puke alone would finish me off. You're a braver gal than I am, Gunga Marie.

Marie said...

Actually, after the initial murder, the Killing was actually not that violent. A few moments here and there, but it focused more on human stories, and nobody got rolled in sick. It's worth a try.

InvisibleWoman said...

Yes, some hiding behind the sofa moments to be sure. But worth hanging in there for more of that gorgeous lawyer who ended up taking the driving offences (I'm so bad at names). Plus there's sod all else to watch on a Saturday night if the sight of Ant and Dec engenders feelings similar to being punched in the stomach a la Tyson. Laure and Lund obviously went to acting school together, knitwear apart. I need more back story though. Why does she not want to go home and get a jumper?

Rob Buckley said...

The "gorgeous lawyer" is Pierre Clement (Gregory Fitoussi). You may have seen him as The Baron in GI Joe of all things.

My review here (probably in it for the long haul, as per season 2): http://www.the-medium-is-not-enough.com/2011/04/review_engrenages_spiral_3x1-3x2.php

Engrenages/Spiral has always been a bit fun with the graphic scenes. Season 1 had the classic one where a drug mule had swallowed his drugs and the police forced him to take a dump on the floor in front of them so they could get the drugs. Except Gilou (IIRC) wanted the drugs so started a fight with the other cops, and while they're having a punch up, the mule extracts the drugs from his stools and eats them again. Ugh...

Anonymous said...

Did I miss the meeting where the French police decided to stay stuck in the 1970s and use the punch first, ask questions later style of interviewing?

Is this really what goes on?

I found Spiral very depressing. Not only was it the lack of jumpers, it was the dog killing, the strange faced silver haired 'judge' who goes around paper indicting people, the 'closed because i'm a paedophile' sign the police posted in that suspect's door, etc etc.

I'm not sure I can take it all. It doesn't seem like a proper police investigation. Its basically just state sanctioned mocking, intimidation and violence. I don't get the impression they would care much if they got the wrong guy, a la Lund.

Oh Saturday. What shall I do now?

Rob Buckley said...

"Is this really what goes on?"

Don't know. But the producers said that they wanted to create a show that depicts the French justice system as it's actually experienced by regular people, rather than the standard depiction, so if they've done their research yes - maybe a bit more dramaticised. So it's less of a murder-mystery like The Killing and more grounded in modern crime fiction, like The Wire.

One of the things that characterised previous seasons (my second season episodic reviews start here) is that each episode would have a "b-plot" which looked at some aspect of the French justice and make you go "WTF?", such as the lack of witness protection programme, the treatment of domestic violence and rape victims, et al. So there'll be more of that to come.

mark and howard said...

yes indeed. a rolling in sick too far, and an off-the-shoulder skinny tee is not a jumper. is it a cartoon? is the french legal system so far different from my imaginings? perhaps. if it gets any crazier, i might get more interested. but oh for the kinder, gentler world of the Killing.

Rob Buckley said...

"is the french legal system so far different from my imaginings?"

Probably. The feedback I've seen from French people living in France with experience is that while this is a "more dramatic" version of what the police are like, they are somewhat "over-zealous" in real-life. Not Greek police over-zealous, but a tad 70s in their approach.

mark and howard said...

hm. thought so. once i imagined a biscuit, and it was much worse in real life. it seems it is ever thus, or at least the evidence is gathering.
whatever, i am a bit fed up of watching nastiness like this, although it is tempting to keep watching to see just how nasty it can get. in the same way i continue to eat biscuits, keeping hope alive.

Alexandra said...

Here is my review of Spiral: Gregory Fitoussi is back. He is unbelievably Fitoussi. He is Fitoussi-issimo.

kiwi said...

Not near as good as the killing but I'll probably keep watching for at least a few more episodes to see where it goes